The two leads who play Lucy and Stephen discuss the finale's major twists, this season's most toxic moments and their hopes for a potential third season in a chat with The Hollywood Reporter.

The actress says she was wondering ahead of the finale, "How do they top the rest of the season and also sum everything up?" — and they did just that Warning: this post contains spoilers for the season 2 finale of Tell Me Lies.

Jackson White discusses what it takes to get into the mindset of a revenge-seeking narcissist in Hulu's 'Tell Me Lies.'

White tells PEOPLE what finale reveal he found "crazy" and weighs in on whether or not he's rooting for Stephen and Lucy

Thomas Doherty spills on the "monstrous and horrible" finale fight between his character and Jackson White, as he says he was "kind of hoping" it was coming